Japan: how to respond?

close

At Campfire you can interact with other members of the COMPANY tribe, share ideas, and discuss. Post anything you want (respectfully please) about artwork you've seen, artists you love, opinions and critiques, rants and support of events you're attending...the forum is yours.

Click on +SPEAK UP to start a new campfire. Start a conversation by writing text, uploading an image, or by copying an article to share. See something inspiring? Click on an image to the right to jump straight to that mini- campfire and then click +ADD COMMENT and join the discussion.

Campfires are sorted by most recent post. An archive of older discussions can be found below.

DON'T HAVE AN ACCOUNT? Create an Account >

Registration is free and will give you full access
to everything Welcome to Company has to offer

Japan: how to respond?

Impressive article on art/japan:

 

The creative community, appalled by events in Japan, has rushed to help. But is the resultant plethora of fundraising prints and posters an adequate or appropriate response? And does visual communications have a longer-term role to play in disaster relief?

Just as happened with Haiti, almost as soon as news of the awful earthquake in Japan spread across the world, they started to appear: fund-raising posters produced by designers, ad agencies and illustrators anxious to do their bit. The logic is straightforward - buy the poster and the proceeds go to aid those in need.

But this approach has not gone unquestioned. There's a good debate about the issues over at Eye plus Johnson Banks has also summarised the arguments on its Thought for the Week page. In a piece for the Fast Company website, writer John Pavlus called a poster (above) created by Signalnoise that has raised over $7000 for the Canadian Red Cross "fundamentally grotesque". "Shouldn't our desire to donate come from actual compassion, not as a side effect of our fascination with pretty artifacts?" Pavlus asked.

The QBN forum has also been debating the topic, asking whether the desire to create such posters is driven as much by self-promotion as it is by a genuine desire to help. And just what are the buyers of such posters supposed to do with them once they get them home? Does anyone really want an image of a crying Japanese flag hanging on their wall? Is such a poster's presence serving merely, as Pavlus writes, "as some sick, bragging monument to my own willingness to 'help'?"

These are important questions to ask, but I really don't believe such posters' makers are primarily or even substantially motivated by self-promotion. It seems to me entirely legitimate that imagemakers should respond to an urge to help by making an image - it's what they do. It's why musicians, respond to the same urge with benefit gigs or charity records.

Why do we have to buy things at all in order to donate? Shouldn't we just donate directly to charity without acquiring a poster or a CD along the way?

Many do just that, but the history of charity fundraising suggests that, as humans, we often need a little prompting in order to contribute. Everything from Live Aid, through charity auctions down to a raffle for the local hospice or a sponsored walk for a day centre exists because of this. In an ideal world, we would all make charitable donations entirely unbidden, but experience shows that sometimes we need helping along, whether by a concert from a favourite band or just by an old lady shaking a collecting tin and giving us a sticker.

One of the organisations that is involved on the ground in Japan is ShelterBox which delivers emergency aid via distinctive green boxes packed with vital equipment and supplies.

 

Go to the Get Involved section on its website and its position seems quite clear "By organising, or taking part in an event that raises funds for ShelterBox," it says "you will be directly providing aid for people affected by disasters all over the world." For an imagemaker, a simple and cost-effective way to do that is to make a print and sell it. In doing so, chances are they will end up channeling more much-needed cash ShelterBox's way than if they had just stuck their hand in their pocket and donated directly.

Perhaps some of our community's unease over the charity poster stems from feelings of inadequacy in comparison to other areas of design. Architects, for example, with a desire to assist disaster relief have the skills to design emergency shelters. Product designers can create simple, cheap forms of heating food. Is a poster really the best we can do? What can visual communicators do to directly influence operations on the ground?

One possible answer was proposed by Gert Dumbar and his son Derk in 2007. A Safe Place is a system of pictograms designed as a tool for communication between aid workers and victims of disasters. Giving people in disaster areas good and accurate information, the theory goes, can save many lives.

Are there other, similarly practical ways in which visual communicators can get involved? It's something we are going to look at in the May issue of CR but if readers know of more examples, please let us know in the comments below.

Such projects would give our community the chance to get involved at a deeper, more long-term level. Reactive fundraising is valuable and welcome, but it also would be good to see visual communicators affecting disaster relief on the ground in a similarly positive way. Hopefully, our forthcoming piece will point up some opportunities.

All this has been on my mind of late not just because of the online debates but also because I have been involved in attempting to organise a response to the Japan disaster from the creative community.

Just over a week ago, a prominent designer called. He wanted to do something to help Japan, could CR help? The designer contacted friends and colleagues, many of whom had friends in Japan and who felt a great affinity for the country. All were keen to help in addition to donating money themselves, but how?

For a group of people with limited resources, selling Giclée prints is do-able and it's effective. A very high proportion of the money raised in this way goes to the charity concerned as there are few up-front costs. Organisations like ShelterBox and the Red Cross who are engaged on the ground in Japan need cash and they need it quickly. Selling prints will provide it, so that route seemed sensible as a first response.

But it also seemed necessary to divorce the works from the disaster itself. There's no need to illustrate what just happened, and no need to raise awareness. Contributors have been asked to concentrate not on the disaster but on why they love Japan, what makes it beautiful, unique and important to them. In this way we hope that the prints will have a longer life and will act not as a reminder of something awful but as a reminder of a moment when the creative community came together to support their friends and colleagues at a time of great need.

But what else can we do? A lot of people have offered items for auction, so that will happen soon. But besides fundraising, can this community help on the ground in any meaningful way? Do you know of any ways in which it is already doing so? Can we help to make sure that agencies are better equipped to respond to any future disaster?

Can we create a model for future disaster responses by the creative community? We will be setting up a website to act as a forum for suggestions and debate. We will be contacting Japanese designers and NGOs for their views but we would like to invite all CR readers to advise us also. Please let us know your suggestions in the comments below. If you know of anyone else who is already tackling these issues, please give us details.

http://bit.ly/hjChgG

 

Posted by: Larson22

Comments

There is an interesting dialogue going on in the comments section of that article.

There are two things that hit me with this--

1. In disaster situations, is the role of creative people/arts solely to raise funds?

2. What other ways can the community really make a difference?

To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

Curated Discussion

Latest Conversation

I am self taught & i love what do. I hope you will receive these well. Thank You, Catherine
There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made sure nice factors in options...
It’s arduous to search out knowledgeable folks on this subject, however you sound like you...
Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn anything like this before. So good to search out someone...
There may be noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you made certain good points in...
Would you be excited about exchanging links?
There may be noticeably a bundle to find out about this. I assume you made certain nice factors in...
This actually answered my problem, thank you! Coax cable...
You made some respectable points there. I seemed on the internet for the problem and located most...
It’s hard to find knowledgeable folks on this topic, but you sound like you know what you’re...
After examine a couple of of the weblog posts in your website now, and I actually like your way of...
very nice publish, i actually love this website, keep on it
This web page can be a walk-via for all of the information you wanted about this and didn’t know...
This really answered my drawback, thank you!
I found your blog web site on google and test just a few of your early posts. Proceed to keep up...
The following time I read a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I...
When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now...
Spot on with this write-up, I really assume this web site wants way more consideration. I’ll in...
Aw, this was a really nice post. In concept I want to put in writing like this moreover – taking...
There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made certain good factors in options...
This is the proper weblog for anyone who desires to search out out about this topic. You realize a...
You should participate in a contest for probably the greatest blogs on the web. I will recommend...
A formidable share, I just given this onto a colleague who was doing just a little evaluation on...
I'm typically to blogging and i actually recognize your content. The article has really peaks my...